Some Assets are Too Important for One Crazy to Control
By almost any measure, America’s most powerful companies now control things that used to belong to the public. They run the roads we drive on, the networks that carry our calls, the satellites that guide our ships, and the servers that hold our private lives. When a handful of billionaires can switch those systems on and off, that’s not just a business story. It’s a national security story.
Take satellite internet. Musk built a constellation of thousands of satellites that now provides connectivity to soldiers, disaster zones, and rural towns. Whether that network operates in a war zone has reportedly come down to the mood of one man. That’s the definition of a risk no serious country should accept.
How to Take Back Control
First, the law already allows government seizure of private assets. The federal government has seized railroads, coal mines, and steel mills during wars. It took over airports after 9/11. It bailed out banks and carmakers and then owned big chunks of them. Under emergency powers and eminent domain, Washington can take private property for public good as long as it pays fair value. And, “fair value” doesn’t necessarily mean money.
Nationalizing doesn’t mean stealing. It means buying or trading — at a price set through negotiation, not the owner’s whim. The US Government could even fine Musk for all his crimes, confiscating StarShield and other assets critical to national security. Taxpayers become shareholders. Profits that once went to Musk fund schools, bridges, or lower taxes. In the case of naturalized citizens like Musk, the government can allow him to keep his US citizenship in exchange for certain assets. Or, conversely, if Musk renounces his citizenship, the government could seize all his assets as threats to national security.
Third, some assets are natural monopolies. You can’t build a second electrical grid or a competing GPS. When competition is impossible, private ownership becomes a toll booth on the whole country. Public ownership ends the middleman.
Critics will say government runs things badly. Sometimes true. But the government also runs the air traffic control system, the interstate highway system, and Social Security — all competently enough that nobody wants them privatized.
The real question isn’t whether markets work. It’s whether a democracy should let unelected billionaires hold veto power over infrastructure everyone depends on. Some things are simply too important to be left to the whims of oligarchs.
NB – Paul Krugman expressed this exact sentiment on October 22, 2026. I asked Proton Lumo to write the first draft about a week after StarShield in Ukraine was throttled on Oct0ber 13, 2026 but got sidetracked by reports of sexual assault at the University of Arizona. Bottom line, it seems this idea is not as farfetched as Proton Lumo first reported.
This post was originally drafted with Proton Lumo AI but the final post, including edits that bypass and/or violate Proton Lumo guardrails are the Author’s alone.